| Year | Player | Position |
| 1914 | Boyd Cherry | E |
| 1916 | Chic Harley | B |
| 1916 | Robert Karch | T |
| 1917 | Charles Bolen | E |
| 1917 | Harold Courtney | E |
| 1917 | Chic Harley | E |
| 1917 | Kelley Van Dyne | C |
| 1918 | Clarence MacDonald | E |
| 1919 | Chic Harley | B |
| 1919 | Gaylord Stinchcomb | B |
| 1920 | Iolas Huffman | G |
| 1920 | Gaylord Stinchcomb | B |
| 1921 | Iolas Huffman | T |
| 1921 | Cyril Myers | E |
| 1923 | Harry Workman | QB |
| 1924 | Harold Cunningham | E |
| 1925 | Edwin Hess | G |
| 1926 | Edwin Hess | G |
| 1926 | Martin Karow | HB |
| 1926 | Leo Raskowski | T |
| 1928 | Leo Raskowski | T |
| 1928 | Wesley Fesler | E |
| 1929 | Wesley Fesler | E |
| 1930 | Wesley Fesler | E |
| 1930 | Lew Hinchman | HB |
| 1931 | Carl Cramer | QB |
| 1931 | Lew Hinchman | HB |
| 1932 | Joseph Gailus | G |
| 1932 | Lew Hinchman | HB |
| 1933 | Joseph Gailus | G |
| 1934 | Regis Monahan | G |
| 1934 | Merle Wendt | E |
| 1935 | Gomer Jones | C |
| 1935 | Merle Wendt | E |
| 1936 | Charles Hamrick | T |
| 1936 | Inwood Smith | G |
| 1936 | Merle Wendt | E |
| 1937 | Carl Kaplanoff | T |
| 1937 | Jim McDonald | QB |
| 1937 | Ralph Wolf | C |
| 1937 | Gust Zarnas | G |
| 1939 | Vic Marino | G |
| 1939 | Esco Sarkkinen | E |
| 1939 | Donald Scott | HB |
| 1940 | Donald Scott | HB |
| 1942 | Robert Shaw | E |
| 1942 | Charles Csuri | T |
| 1942 | Lindell Houston | G |
| 1942 | Paul Sarringhaus | HB |
| 1943 | William Willis | T |
| 1944 | Jack Dugger | E |
| 1944 | William Hackett | G |
| 1944 | Les Horvath | QB/HB |
| 1944 | William Willis | T |
| 1945 | Warren Amling | G |
| 1945 | Ollie Cline | FB |
| 1945 | Russell Thomas | T |
| 1946 | Warren Amling | T |
| 1946 | Cecil Souders | E |
| 1950 | Victor Janowicz | HB |
| 1950 | Robert McCullough | C |
| 1950 | Robert Momsen | G |
| 1952 | Mike Takacs | G |
| 1954 | Dean Dugger | E |
| 1954 | Howard Cassady | B |
| 1955 | Howard Cassady | B |
| 1955 | James Parker | G |
| 1956 | James Parker | G |
| 1957 | Aurealius Thomas | G |
| 1958 | James Houston | E |
| 1958 | James Marshall | T |
| 1958 | Bob White | FB |
| 1959 | James Houston | E |
| 1960 | Robert Ferguson | FB |
| 1961 | Robert Ferguson | FB |
| 1964 | James Davidson | T |
| 1964 | Dwight Kelley | LB |
| 1964 | Arnold Chonko | DB |
| 1965 | Douglas Van Horn | OT |
| 1965 | Dwight Kelley | LB |
| 1966 | Ray Pryor | C |
| 1968 | David Foley | OT |
| 1968 | Rufus Mayes | OT |
| 1969 | James Stillwagon | NG |
| 1969 | Rex Kern | QB |
| 1969 | Jim Otis | FB |
| 1969 | Ted Provost | DB |
| 1969 | Jack Tatum | DB |
| 1970 | Jan White | TE |
| 1970 | James Stillwagon | NG |
| 1970 | John Brockington | FB |
| 1970 | Jack Tatum | DB |
| 1970 | Mike Sensibaugh | DB |
| 1970 | Tim Anderson | DB |
| 1971 | Tom DeLeone | C |
| 1972 | John Hicks | OT |
| 1972 | Randy Gradishar | LB |
| 1973 | Van Ness DeCree | DE |
| 1973 | John Hicks | OT |
| 1973 | Randy Gradishar | LB |
| 1973 | Archie Griffin | TB |
| 1974 | Van Ness DeCree | DE |
| 1974 | Kurt Schumacher | OT |
| 1974 | Pete Cusick | DT |
| 1974 | Steve Myers | C |
| 1974 | Archie Griffin | TB |
| 1974 | Neal Colzie | DB |
| 1974 | Tom Skladany | P |
| 1975 | Ted Smith | OG |
| 1975 | Ted Smith | OG |
| 1975 | Archie Griffin | TB |
| 1975 | Tim Fox | DB |
| 1975 | Tom Skladany | PT |
| 1976 | Bob Brudzinski | DE |
| 1976 | Chris Ward | OT |
| 1976 | Tom Skladany | P |
| 1977 | Chris Ward | OT |
| 1977 | Aaron Brown | NG |
| 1977 | Tom Cousineau | LB |
| 1977 | Ray Griffin | DB |
| 1978 | Tom Cousineau | LB |
| 1979 | Ken Fritz | OG |
| 1979 | Art Schichter | QB |
| 1982 | Marcus Marek | LB |
| 1984 | James Lachey | OG |
| 1984 | Keith Byars | TB |
| 1985 | Thomas Johnson | LB |
| 1986 | Cris Carter | SE |
| 1986 | Chris Spielman | LB |
| 1987 | Chris Spielman | LB |
| 1987 | Tom Tupa | P |
| 1988 | Jeff Uhlenhake | C |
| 1991 | Steve Tovar | LB |
| 1992 | Steve Tovar | LB |
| 1993 | Korey Stringer | OT |
| 1993 | Dan Wilkinson | DT |
| 1994 | Korey Stringer | OT |
| 1995 | Eddie George | TB |
| 1995 | Terry Glenn | FL |
| 1995 | Orlando Pace | OT |
| 1995 | Mike Vrabel | DE |
| 1996 | Orlando Pace | OT |
| 1996 | Shawn Springs | CB |
| 1996 | Mike Vrabel | DE |
| 1997 | Andy Katzenmoyer | LB |
| 1997 | Rob Murphy | OG |
| 1997 | Antoine Winfield | DB |
| 1998 | David Boston | WR |
| 1998 | Damon Moore | DB |
| 1998 | Rob Murphy | OL |
| 1998 | Antoine Winfield | DB |
| 1999 | Na'il Diggs | LB |
| 2000 | Mike Doss | S |
| 2001 | LeCharles Bentley | C |
| 2001 | Mike Doss | S |
| 2002 | Mike Doss | S |
| 2002 | Matt Wilhelm | LB |
| 2003 | Will Allen | S |
| 2003 | Will Smith | DE |